Prop Trading vs Managed Accounts (PAMM/MAM)

Key Highlights

Prop trading is ideal for disciplined traders with limited capital, as it entails trading a firm’s capital in return for a percentage of the profits. PAMM/MAM, on the other hand, are managed account solutions where money managers use individual investors’ or pooled funds to generate passive income for investors.

In a nutshell, these are their key differences:

• In a PAMM, the manager trades one large pool, and the software distributes the P/L. In a MAM, the manager can actually adjust the multiplier for each sub-account.
• Prop trading is for single traders, and PAMM/MAM are for money managers
• MAM permits the use of diverse strategies for different investors

Prop Trading vs Managed Accounts (PAMM/MAM)

Most first-time investors and traders treat prop trading, MAM, and PAMM as one and the same thing.

And this is why many beginner traders start by asking the wrong question! Often, you’ll find  that the first question every individual interested in trading asks is, “How much capital should I raise to begin trading?”

For them, this question seems alright. However, what it tells you about the person asking it, is more focused on the result than on anything else. What happens in most cases is that when a person starts trading with “just enough” capital, it means that they are risking funds that they can’t afford to lose on a trading process that they don’t fully understand.

It’s why the right question for anyone interested in trading and investing should always be, “What do I need to get started?” In this case, the answer will be quite simple: to understand the differences between these three methods of trading!

In this guide, you’ll learn what each means, you’ll even get a detailed comparison of prop trading vs managed accounts. Read on to learn more about these different methods of trading. 

What Is Prop Trading?

Proprietary trading allows you to use a demo account where trades are mirrored to lower your personal financial risk. The prop firm then shares the profits generated based on your trading performance. Often, traders typically keep between 50% and 95% of profits

If you’re an experienced trader, partnering with a prop trading firm provides access to significant capital and professional tools to use advanced trading technology and trade with large amounts of money. You also get to use professional tools that you may not be able to access when trading on your own.

In return for providing you with virtual funding and the tools needed to generate profits, the financial company gets to retain a percentage of the profits, while you take the remainder home. Unlike normal trading or investing with personal funds, this model comes with a strict evaluation phase.

Test your trading strategy with a free challenge and prove your consistency

Join the Free Prop Firm Trading Competition

Test your trading strategy with a free challenge and prove your consistency

Join the Free Prop Firm Trading Competition

The purpose of this evaluation is to establish whether you possess the skills needed to effectively manage capital, observe trading rules, and generate profits. Passing this evaluation will open you up to a whole new world of trading possibilities.

Disclaimer: Evaluations have a very high failure rate. Prop trading involves high psychological pressure, and "virtual funding" does not mean "easy money."

Learn more about latest guide Compare Prop trading to other models

Why Prop Trading Exists

In the early days, prop trading was a preserve of hedge funds and big banks. Skilled traders were then hired and given access to firm money for use in speculative trading activities in pursuit of big gains. But this has changed in the past decade, thanks to the advent of new tech systems.

Independent companies, known as prop firms, are today able to provide access to performance-based funding agreements. In modern retail prop firms, traders often operate in simulated environments during evaluation phases, with payouts based on performance. However, traditional prop trading involves using real firm capital.

Please note that in retail prop trading, the "capital" is typically virtual, and the payout is a contractual performance bonus rather than a direct share of live market liquidity.

So, why do these financial companies exist?

• Accessible Trading: To provide skilled individuals with limited capital with a way into the trading world
• Scalable Model: They can use technology to onboard thousands of remote traders worldwide
• Shared Profits: The prop firms benefit when their remote traders perform well in the markets

Prop trading is a partnership between you and the prop firm: if you do well, you both win.

Pro Tip for Prop Traders: Check the "Consistency Rule" and "News Trading" restrictions before paying for an evaluation. These are often the reasons traders lose their accounts even when profitable.

PAMM and MAM – The Beginner Trader’s Guide

PAMM and MAM accounts are structures that allow professional traders to manage multiple investor accounts efficiently and transparently. These two allow a single Master Account to execute trades for hundreds of Investor Accounts simultaneously, which is the standard technical solution for licensed managers handling external capital under a broker. You’ll find that there are clients who want full automation, while others will demand increased flexibility. On the same note, there are those who prefer pooled funds, with others opting for individual control. Understanding how each works can help simplify the trading process.

What Is a PAMM Account?

The Percentage Allocation Management Module (PAMM) is among the most commonly used methods by investors looking to tap into the expertise of skilled traders. These accounts provide a way through which investors can pool their funds under the control of one professional money manager, thus enabling them to create a streamlined profit-sharing system.

A financial broker interested in deploying a PAMM system will need to make sure that they have selected the right tech systems. Ideally, the right PAMM platform will provide transparent reporting, automated trade execution, and most importantly, a seamless profit distribution system.

How Do PAMM Accounts Work?

The PAMM model operates on a pretty straightforward principle: several investors join hands and entrust their money to a professional trader who is tasked with executing trades on their behalf. All profits and losses are then shared based on the amount of money that each investor has staked. The best part about it is that every aspect is transparent and automated, guaranteeing a fair distribution system.

You can think of the PAMM model as a pooled investment vehicle, but without the complexity brought about by direct fund transfers. In this managed pool, the money manager focuses on making trades, and investors are able to track the performance of the trades executed by the trader on a real-time basis.

Become a Funded Trader Today

Join the Funded Trader Program

Become a Funded Trader Today

Join the Funded Trader Program

What Is a MAM Account?

The Multi Account Manager (MAM) system is unlike the PAMM model, which focuses on a pooled investment structure. In MAM, the investor has more control over the trade allocation as well as the risk management plan practiced, making it a favorite for Money Managers who need to set different risk levels for different clients.

Using a MAM solution, the traders are able to provide customized trade allocations, multi-level account access, and real-time risk management.

Pro Tip for Managed Account Investors: Always ask for a "Myfxbook" or "Verified Track Record" and check if the manager uses a "High-Water Mark" (meaning they only get paid when the account hits new profit peaks).

Summary of PAMM vs MAM

PAMM (Percentage Allocation Management Module): Think of this as a "Mutual Fund" for Forex. All investor money is pooled into one large account. If the manager buys 10 lots and you own 10% of the pool, you are effectively responsible for 1 lot. Profits and losses are distributed proportionally.

MAM (Multi-Account Manager): This is a more advanced version of a PAMM. It allows the manager to treat each investor's account as a separate entity. The manager can assign different "leverage" or "risk levels" to different accounts based on the individual investor's risk appetite. MAM is better for investors with high capital who require specific risk parameters (e.g., lower leverage than the rest of the pool)

Note: Remember to check local regulations: Ensure the broker offering the PAMM/MAM is regulated in a jurisdiction that protects your funds.

Table Comparison of Prop Trading vs Managed Accounts

Prop trading is a performance-based funding model, while PAMM/MAM are typically offered by brokers and often used by professional or experienced money managers

The table below helps explain the differences between prop trading and managed accounts:

Why the Distinction Between Prop Trading and Managed Accounts Matters?

The right choice depends on your goal. If you are a trader who wants to get paid for your skill without risking your life savings, Prop Trading is your path. If you are an investor who has capital but lacks the time or skill to trade, Managed Accounts allow you to leverage someone else's expertise.

Trade with Audacity Capital

Get Funded Now

Trade with Audacity Capital

Get Funded Now

Conclusion

Prop trading is designed for tried and tested traders who possess the skills needed to generate profits but lack enough trading balance to do it on their own. The prop firm steps in to fill in the funding gap in return for a share of the profits made. Managed accounts (PAMM and MAM), on the other hand, are ideal for investors looking to earn a passive income. Profits in managed accounts are split based on the lot sizes or investment percentage.

FAQs